Onwards and Sideways Review
· wildlife
“Onwards and Sideways” Review: A Stirring Lesson on Acceptance
In an era where disease narratives have become increasingly prevalent in film, John Madden’s Onwards and Sideways offers a refreshing take on the genre. This dramedy about two individuals diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease on the same day at the same clinic may not break new ground, but it succeeds in avoiding formulaic pitfalls through its script.
The film’s portrayal of living with a chronic illness is strikingly authentic, thanks to Paul Mayhew-Archer’s firsthand perspective as someone living with Parkinson’s since 2011. However, this authenticity also raises questions about the reliance on familiar storylines. Rhys Ifans’ performance as Tony, a primary school teacher struggling to come to terms with his diagnosis, is achingly thoughtful, but there’s a sense that we’re witnessing a well-worn path.
Laura Linney shines as Emma, an outgoing American composer who chooses to confront her illness head-on. Her character’s determination to maintain her idealism in the face of diminishing capability serves as a poignant reminder that people with Parkinson’s are not defined by their diagnosis. The supporting cast, including Rory Kinnear and Monica Dolan, add depth to the narrative without detracting from the central performances.
The film’s ability to balance humor and pathos is a testament to Mayhew-Archer’s script. The harrowing night terrors experienced by Tony serve as a stark reminder of the physical manifestations of Parkinson’s, but they also provide a window into the emotional toll of living with a chronic illness. Thomas Newman’s score, while effective in conveying the emotional weight of the narrative, highlights the need for more nuanced soundscapes in disease narratives.
Ultimately, Onwards and Sideways reveals that it is still bound by the conventions of the disease narrative genre. Despite this limitation, the film serves as a reminder that even in the most challenging circumstances, there is room for growth, acceptance, and humor. As the film prepares to find its audience, it’s worth remembering that the most compelling stories are often those that challenge our expectations – and Onwards and Sideways does just that, offering a poignant exploration of living with chronic illnesses.
Reader Views
- TFThe Field Desk · editorial
The film's portrayal of Parkinson's is undeniably authentic, but we need to consider the cost of relying on familiar narratives: do these stories ultimately perpetuate ableism by reinforcing stereotypes and reifying illness as a personal struggle? By focusing on individual experiences, disease narratives can overlook systemic issues – access to healthcare, support services, and research funding. A more nuanced approach would acknowledge that living with Parkinson's is not just about resilience or tragedy, but also about policy changes and collective action.
- ACAlex C. · amateur naturalist
One of the most striking aspects of Onwards and Sideways is its portrayal of the emotional toll of living with Parkinson's. However, I'd argue that the film reinforces a familiar trope: the "grit and determination" narrative, which can be alienating for those who don't experience their condition in this way. We need more nuanced depictions of coping mechanisms – some people may not choose to confront their illness head-on, but rather find ways to adapt and accept its presence in their lives.
- DWDr. Wren H. · ecologist
While _Onwards and Sideways_ brings much-needed authenticity to disease narratives, I'm concerned that its portrayal of Parkinson's may inadvertently perpetuate ableism by emphasizing Tony's struggles while glossing over Emma's determination as a coping mechanism rather than a nuanced expression of agency. The film's attempt to humanize illness risks reducing complex experiences to a simplistic "fight" narrative, ignoring the many individuals who navigate chronic conditions with resilience and adaptability, not just defiance. A more thoughtful exploration of able-bodied privilege and its impact on people living with Parkinson's would have elevated this otherwise sincere effort.