MothsLife

Carlton close on AFL top 10 finish

· wildlife

The Dark Clouds Gathering Over St Kilda’s AFLW Ambitions

The Sunday night game at Marvel Stadium saw Carlton’s revival story unfold, while St Kilda’s woes continued to mount. Carlton’s impressive resurgence under interim coach Josh Fraser has left them two games clear of injury-stricken St Kilda, who lost their AFLW opener without key player Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera and managed only eight goals against a formidable Blues defense.

Fraser’s tenure has been marked by his ability to adapt and dominate possession. In this 44-point victory over the Saints, he orchestrated another masterful performance from his team, with Francis Evans standing out – racking up 22 disposals, 12 inside 50s, and a goal.

St Kilda’s struggles are alarming. Despite an off-season spending spree that brought in high-profile recruits, they face the prospect of missing the finals for the third consecutive season. The loss of Wanganeen-Milera, who was replaced by Mason Wood on the sidelines with a calf injury, proved to be the decisive blow for Ross Lyon’s men.

The Saints’ injury list reads like a roll call of AFLW stars, with key players Max King and Jack Sinclair ruled out for the season. It is little wonder that Lyon will face significant pressure to turn St Kilda’s fortunes around next year – and whether he can work his magic again remains to be seen.

Carlton’s resurgence under Fraser stands in stark contrast to St Kilda’s struggles. While Carlton’s revival is a testament to Fraser’s leadership, St Kilda’s woes highlight the long-term challenges facing Lyon in his final season at the helm. The pressure on Lyon to deliver is mounting by the day, and it remains to be seen whether he can overcome the weight of expectation and guide his team towards the finals.

With two rounds remaining, St Kilda’s chances of avoiding another finals drought are slim. Their injury curse continues to ravage their campaign, leaving Lyon facing a daunting task in the months ahead – one that will test his mettle as a coach like never before.

Reader Views

  • AC
    Alex C. · amateur naturalist

    The real concern for St Kilda isn't just their current form, but their lack of depth in key positions. Despite a big off-season spend, they're still struggling to match Carlton's consistency. With so many star players ruled out for the season, Ross Lyon's biggest challenge will be building a strong team culture and developing talent from within, rather than relying on expensive imports who aren't delivering results. It's one thing to fix a team's short-term woes, but can Lyon build something sustainable for the future?

  • TF
    The Field Desk · editorial

    While Carlton's resurgence under Josh Fraser is undoubtedly impressive, one can't help but wonder if the club's new coach has simply inherited a talented young team, rather than building a sustainable foundation from scratch. The Blues' recent success masks some of the underlying issues that led to their 2022 wooden spoon, and it's still unclear whether Fraser's coaching prowess will be enough to propel them into the top four. Meanwhile, Ross Lyon faces an existential crisis at St Kilda, with his own legacy on the line as he struggles to turn around a team crippled by injury and underperforming recruits.

  • DW
    Dr. Wren H. · ecologist

    Carlton's revival is more than just a pleasant surprise - it's a testament to the team's ability to adapt and thrive in adversity. Meanwhile, St Kilda's struggles highlight the darker side of AFLW's emphasis on spectacle over sustainability. As we lavish attention on high-profile recruits and expensive imports, our focus on grassroots development and player welfare suffers. With injury lists growing longer by the season, it's only a matter of time before the financial strain starts to show. The pressure is mounting for Ross Lyon, but perhaps more pressing is the need for genuine long-term planning, rather than just a quick fix in the off-season.

Related articles

More from MothsLife

View as Web Story →